I had to laugh after I cried.
My sons attend a local church on Wednesday Nights to hang out with their Christian friends from school. My youngest attends AWANA, and my two middle sons and our adopted son attends the youth group. This is all due to the kindness of a local pastor who has been very gracious to help us as we are launching our church in this community.
Recently, the youth pastor was involved in a car accident where he died. He was a great kid, loved the scripture, loved the Lord. Long story short, my boys are experiencing their 4th youth pastor in the two years since we have been here. This is where this story begins.
A young lady, a campus crusader, has taken the reins as the new youth leader at this local fellowship. She is one who I witnessed to at the campus because she had difficulty articulating how one gets saved, and how one is led to the Lord. Now I believe that she truly loves the Lord, this is not at issue, here. What is at issue is that she has been showing Nooma Videos in youth group recently. My son Eddie came home and complained about it last night. This is the sad part; she is showing Nooma Videos while my son (and others) hunger and thirst for the Word to be taught. This is what youth groups ought to be for, to build up these young people to be young men and ladies of God. Instead, we have pizza, popcorn, and Noomas. We are setting these kids up for failure when they leave for college.
I am not worried about my sons and ‘adopted’ sons, for they are taught at home. They are also taught on Sunday mornings by one of my elders. They apparently know the Word very well, for my son Eddie in his complaint made me very happy…and this is the laughter part. He said that Rob Bell was gay- which is his way of saying that he is stupid and makes no sense. I asked him what he means, and he explained that it seems that on these videos, Rob Bell talks a lot about nothing, that there is no organized thought, that it seems he tells stories and then tries to jam scriptures into the stories to make his point. Then, my son said, most of the time he does not even reference scripture, so it seems that he is changing what it says so he can make his point.
Now this morning, I inquired further, and one of my ‘adopted’ kids who is very young in the Lord piped in about the lack of sense and the lack of scripture and any cogent teaching. He says that the videos are well produced, but stupid, because they make absolutely no sense to him. They are boring.
This is what made me laugh. Rob Bell is trying to be relevant, trying to reach a new generation with this garbage he calls Noomas, and it is not even reaching its target audience. To these young Bible fed teens, this teaching is irrelevant when compared to the scripture!
Now you may be thinking that I have coached my kids, or that I am misquoting them. I assure you, this is not happening. I am telling you that they love the Word. I am telling you that they have studied it enough to know what it says. I am telling you that they recognize error. I am telling you that a 14 year old and a 15 year old and a 16 year old do know about exegesis and eisogesis and can recognize the difference~(thanks to a little product called Herman-who?).
Which makes me think further that his market, young or old, is not those who are saved and love the Word of God. His market is to the post-modern who believes that truth is relative only to his or her own experience. His market is for those who are too lazy to open up God’s Word and experience it for themselves. His market is for non believers and false converts who want a feel-good religious experience. What I am saying is that Noomas are not for the church, for those who believe that the Bible is the Word of God, and that we are saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone.
I am thankful that my kids recognize error. I am sad that there are many more who drink this poison in like water.
You actually nailed it a couple of times here (I’m trying to be generous). I am the senior pastor at a C&MA church (as are you), and I minister specifically to postmodern college students who believe (just like you said) that all truth is relative.
Using Bells material, we’ve have 12 people become followers of Christ through this ministry. 3 of them actually went on to a “reformed” view of the Gospel… and they were previously agnostic.
Grace and Peace
I am thankful that new believers are finding Nooma. What a great simple tool to teach truth.
I hope your sons will benefit as much as I have from the teachings of Rob Bell.
BTW, do you not consider your adopted son a son? I have an adopted brother ans sister and to me, they are a part of my family, unless I am defending my parents seeing my older brother and sister where born before they got married, I don’t see the end to tell everyone they are adopted. I am just curious why you threw it out there, when referring to him, that he is adopted?
One more question, what does Joe have to do with Nooma? I was just curious why you tagged him in it?
Have a fun day John:-)
[...] sons” of Pastor John Chisham have caught on to the truth of Rob Bell early. According to Pastor Chisham, one of the sons… said that Rob Bell was gay- which is his way of saying that he is stupid [...]
John,
Why the lies? You know Bell has several scriptures for every NOOMA. Oh maybe you don’t cause you consistently say things about him without actually doing research.
If your new leader was doing what I believe she probably was she lead the students through the discussions in, once again, every NOOMA. Which also has scripture listed.
Get off the high horse John, you’re blocking the Sun…err..Son.
chris,
I know Bell has scriptures, and it is mentioned in the above article. Thats why my son noticed that Bell used eisogesis- that is jamming scripture (his words) into his philosophy or his presentation.
I have watched his noomas. They range from almost acceptable to outright lies and strawmen (see bullhorn). He does not exegete scripture, he proof texts with weak translations all to attempt to make something relevant that already is- scripture.
She is not my leader, by the way. If she were, she would not be using noomas except as a discussion starter on how not to interpret scripture.
Erica,
I tag Joe on anything having to do with Bell.
My ‘adopted’ son is not officially adopted, he just has a very rough home life and lived with us several months. We love him like our own, but he is not officially ours.
Hey Tommy,
I think we were ordained together…
But Bell’s teaching should never substitute for the scripture, and until we have a thorough understanding of scripture, I question even using them. To take mans writings and video musings and elevate them even as tools before we use the scripture is inadvisable in my book.
[...] and it has set them free. They are not spiritually blind, but can see through the lies as we see in this post. These young men would be considered babes in Christ because of their age, but as we see, they most [...]
[...] Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh – Teen added an interesting post on Is Rob Bell Even Relevant?Here’s a small excerpt…thought, that it seems he tells stories and … To these young Bible fed teens, this teaching is … I am telling you that they love the Word. [...]